| Event ID | Date | Time | End | Day | Location | Visitor | V Score | Home | H Score | Status |
| 3230002 | 12/12/2009 | 1:00 PM | 2:00 PM | Sat | Cent / CPL Fieldhouse | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 30 | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 27 | Completed |
| 3230001 | 12/12/2009 | 7:00 PM | 8:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 43 | St. Rita (Bunka) | 16 | Completed |
| 3230003 | 12/12/2009 | 7:00 PM | 8:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 2 | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 35 | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 45 | Completed |
| 3230005 | 12/19/2009 | 1:00 PM | 2:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 26 | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 49 | Completed |
| 3230004 | 12/19/2009 | 7:00 PM | 8:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 17 | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 38 | Completed |
| 3230007 | 1/2/2010 | 4:00 PM | 5:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 30 | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 50 | Completed |
| 3230008 | 1/2/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Rita (Bunka) | 32 | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 46 | Completed |
| 3230012 | 1/9/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 42 | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 40 | Completed |
| 3230009 | 1/9/2010 | 7:00 PM | 8:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 44 | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 40 | Completed |
| 3230010 | 1/9/2010 | 7:30 PM | 8:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 42 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 45 | Completed |
| 3230011 | 1/9/2010 | 7:30 PM | 8:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | St. Rita (Bunka) | 40 | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 30 | Completed |
| 3230013 | 1/16/2010 | 6:00 PM | 7:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | St. Rita (Bunka) | 24 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 30 | Completed |
| 3230014 | 1/16/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 40 | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 55 | Completed |
| 3230015 | 1/16/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 52 | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 36 | Completed |
| 3230016 | 1/16/2010 | 7:00 PM | 8:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 24 | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 38 | Completed |
| 3230017 | 1/23/2010 | 3:00 PM | 4:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 60 | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 18 | Completed |
| 3230018 | 1/23/2010 | 4:00 PM | 5:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | St. Rita (Bunka) | 53 | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 58 | Completed |
| 3230020 | 1/23/2010 | 5:30 PM | 6:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 30 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 42 | Completed |
| 3230019 | 1/23/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 53 | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 20 | Completed |
| 3230021 | 1/30/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 53 | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 37 | Completed |
| 3230022 | 1/30/2010 | 6:30 PM | 7:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 54 | St. Rita (Bunka) | 23 | Completed |
| 3230023 | 1/30/2010 | 7:00 PM | 8:00 PM | Sat | NEO Sports Plant / NEO Sports Plant Court 3 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 28 | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 26 | Completed |
| 3230024 | 1/30/2010 | 7:30 PM | 8:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 64 | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 43 | Completed |
| 3230032 | 1/31/2010 | 2:00 PM | 3:00 PM | Sun | Cent / CPL Fieldhouse | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 35 | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 46 | Completed |
| 3230026 | 2/6/2010 | 2:30 PM | 3:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | Gesu (Kirincic) | 38 | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 26 | Completed |
| 3230025 | 2/6/2010 | 4:30 PM | 5:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | Lake Catholic High School (Freiberg) | 50 | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 35 | Completed |
| 3230028 | 2/6/2010 | 4:30 PM | 5:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 33 | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 38 | Completed |
| 3230027 | 2/6/2010 | 5:30 PM | 6:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 42 | St. Rita (Bunka) | 20 | Completed |
| 3230029 | 2/13/2010 | 11:30 AM | 12:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 42 | Gesu (Kirincic) | 38 | Completed |
| 3230030 | 2/13/2010 | 11:30 AM | 12:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | St. Paschal Baylon (Caporale) | 31 | St. Rita (Bunka) | 29 | Completed |
| 3230031 | 2/13/2010 | 12:30 PM | 1:30 PM | Sat | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Red | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin HS (Frontino) | 37 | St. Gregory the Great (Seither) | 46 | Completed |
| 3230006 | 2/14/2010 | 2:00 PM | 3:00 PM | Sun | Lost / LNSP-Willoughby-Blue | St. Joan of Arc (Lynch) | 32 | St. Gabriel (Traina) | 69 | Completed |